7.25.2006

Academic Freedom-Michael Bérubé

Academic Freedom-Michael Bérubé [speech delivered on June 2006 to the annual meeting of the American Association of University Professors].

A few points I liked:
THE PRINCIPLE OF ACADEMIC FREEDOM stipulates that “teachers are entitled to full freedom in research and in the publication of the results, subject to the adequate performance of their other academic duties”; it insists that professors should have intellectual autonomy from legislatures, trustees, alumni, parents, and ecclesiastical authorities with regard to their teaching and research. In this respect it is one of the legacies of the Enlightenment, which sought—successfully, in those nations most influenced by the Enlightenment—to free scientists and humanists from the dictates of church and state.

I can’t imagine that Vaclav Havel or Lech Walesa would be terribly impressed with Penn State’s Berlin Wall, or the bravery of those who built it. Nor can I imagine that they would think much of a putatively “conservative” movement whose goal it is to place educational institutions directly under the control of the state.

BUT WHERE ARE MY MANNERS? I’ve spent all this time on David Horowitz and the National Association of Scholars, and I haven’t even mentioned the American Council of Trustees and Alumni, even though its president, Anne D. Neal, has come all this way to be with us today. Last month, ACTA published a report titled “How Many Ward Churchills?", which consists largely of course descriptions adduced by ACTA as evidence that American universities are in fact infested by Ward Churchills.

I was asked by a member of the Penn State College Republicans whether I taught “both sides” in my graduate seminar on disability studies. In response, I mentioned the debate over what’s called the ethics of selective abortion of fetuses with disabilities, and briefly sketched out four or five positions on the question. My point, of course, was that just as it is a mistake to think that there are two sides to every question, it is also a mistake—and a pernicious one, encouraged by Horowitz, Balch, and company—to think that there are only two sides to every question.

If you believe in the ideals of the open society and the intellectual legacies of the Enlightenment, you should believe in the ideal of professors’ intellectual independence from the state—and you should believe that it is an ideal worth defending.

But sure go and read the WHOLE ESSAY.

7.24.2006

A Talk with Nobel Prize Winning Author Naguib Mahfouz


A Talk with Nobel Prize Winning Author Naguib Mahfouz

See: The Cruelty of Memory by Edward W. Said.

Carnival of Socialism


Carnival of Socialism #7 is up at Fruits of Our Labor.

Top 15 Socialist Rock Songs include "The Ghost of Tom Joad" by Bruce Springsteen.

Words from that song are used in "The Search for New Metaphors," in Library Trends 46 (Summer 1997).

7.23.2006

Inaugural Dylan Thomas Prize Longlist


The inaugural Dylan Thomas Prize for £60,000 will be awarded to the winner at a glittering prizes event at the Brangwyn Hall in Swansea on 27th October 2006.

The Prize has been designed as a series of events in which, first the short-listed writers, and eventually the winner will appear before writing groups in schools, colleges and communities both in Wales and the United States. In Wales itself, the Welsh Assembly Government and individual private companies are specifically interested in encouraging this social dimension of the Prize. In Wales, as in the English-speaking world as a whole, the enthusiasm of young writers is very evident and the Prize intends to provide one focus for those energies and ambitions.

Susan Barker - Sayonara Bar
Lucy Caldwell - Where They Were Missed
Kira Cochrane - Escape routes for beginners
Rodge Glass - No fireworks
Joey Goebel - Torture The Artist
Ian Holding - Infeeling
Nick Laird - Utterly Monkey and To A Fault
Emily Maguire - Taming the beast
Matthew David Scott - Playing Mercy
James Scudamore - The Amnesia Clinic
Talitha Stevenson - Exposure
Rachel Trezise - Fresh Apples
Liza Ward - Outside Valentine

The shortlist will be revealed in September and the winner of the £60,000 prize will be named at a ceremony at Swansea's Brangwyn Hall on October 27 - the date of Dylan Thomas's birthday.


Swansea is proud of being the birthplace of Dylan Marlais Thomas and also proud to host an annual Dylan Thomas Festival.

7.22.2006

LC is abdicating its professional responsibilities

LC is abdicating its professional responsibilities to the national system of shared cataloging.

"What is Going on at the Library of Congress?" prepared for AFSCME 2910 by Thomas Mann.

ALA Council actions from the 2006 ALA Annual Conference

ALA Council I
Sunday, June 25, 2006
10:45am-12:15pm
Morial Convention Center, La Nouvelle Orleans Ballroom
New Orleans, LA

ADOPTED, ALA CD#2.1, 2006 ALA Midwinter Council Minutes.

APPROVED, The following slate of candidates for the 2006-2007 Council Committee on Committees Election: Bernadine Abbott-Hoduski; Jose Aguinaga; Barbara A. Genco; Norman Maas; Stephen L. Matthews; Robert Randolph Newlen; Jan W. Sanders; and Courtney L. Young. (ALA CD#12, 2005-2006 ALA Council Committee on Committees Report on the Nominations for the 2006-2007 ALA Council Committee on Committees Election)

APPROVED, The following slate of candidates for the 2006-2007 Planning and Budget Assembly Election: Councilors-at-Large: Randall Enos; Bonnie L. Kunzel; Katharine B. Lehman; Virginia Sanchez; Sherrie Schmidt; and Theresa A. Tobin. Chapter Councilors: Sandra M. Barstow; Thomas Kevin Cherry; Jackie Yvonne Griffin; and Vicki L. Gregory. (ALA CD#12.1, 2005-2006 ALA Council Committee on Committees Report on the Nominations for the 2006-2007 ALA Planning and Budget Assembly Election)

REFERRED, To the Committee on Legislation, with a report back to the ALA at the 2006 ALA Annual Conference, ALA CD#48, Resolution Endorsing HR 676 (For Single Payer Universal Health Care and S 2772, The Health Partnership Act), which read: “That the American Library Association endorses HR 676, “Expanded Medicare for All,” a single payer health care program; and that the American Library Association endorses S2772, “Health Care Partnership Act,” as a first step towards affordable quality health care for all; and that the American Library Association works with affiliated organizations and among our own membership to build popular support for these bills; and that the American Library Association sends a copy of this resolution to the President, to all Senators and Representatives and to all State Chapters of ALA.”

ALA Council II
Tuesday, June 27, 2006
9:15am-12:45pm
Morial Convention Center, La Nouvelle Orleans Ballroom

VOTED, To adopt the following three (3) action items contained in ALA CD#17.1, Policy Monitoring Committee Report:

Item 1. Based on CD #13 (Midwinter Meeting 2006), submitted by the ALA Executive Board, approved by the consent of Council, the PMC recommends that Section 1.4 Key Action Areas be changed to read:

Key Action Areas:
•Diversity
•Equitable Access to Information and Library Services
•Education and Lifelong Learning
•Intellectual Freedom
•Advocacy for Libraries and the Profession
•Literacy
•Organizational Excellence
(See “Current Reference File”: ALA Programmatic Priorities: 2005-2006 ALA CD#13)

Item 2: Based on CD #36 (Midwinter Meeting 2006), submitted by Councilor Mark Rosenzweig, approved by the consent of Council, the PMC recommends that this policy be added to the ALA Policy Manual as:

53.5 Support of Academic Freedom
The American Library Association reaffirms the principles of academic freedom embodied in the American Association of University Professors’ “Statement on Academic Freedom and Tenure” (1940), and opposes any legislation or codification of documents (e.g. the “Academic Bill of Rights” (ABOR)) that undermine academic or intellectual freedom, chill free speech, and/or otherwise interfere with the academic community’s well-established norms and values of scholarship and educational excellence. (See “Current Reference File”: Resolution in Support of Academic Freedom, 2005-2006 ALA CD#36)

Item 3. Based on CD # 18.2 submitted by The ALA International Relations Committee and approved by the consent of Council, the PMC recommends that this policy be added to the ALA Policy Manual as:

58.5 Rights of Librarians and Library Workers to Travel
The American Library Association affirms and supports the rights of librarians and library workers in or from the U.S. to travel to all countries in order to attend and participate in conferences, to purchase books and other library materials, to meet and develop working relationships with librarians, to develop gift and exchange programs, to pursue and establish ties with library and other professional associations and libraries, and to conduct educational and professional library-related activities. In addition, ALA affirms and supports the rights of librarians and library workers from outside the U.S. to travel to the U.S., and not be prohibited or impeded by U.S. government policies, to attend and participate in conferences, to purchase books, and other library materials, to meet and develop working relationships with librarians and library staff, to develop gift and exchange programs, to pursue and establish ties with library and other professional associations and libraries, and to conduct educational and professional library-related activities. (See “Current Reference File”: Resolution on Rights of Librarians and Library Workers to Travel: 2006-2006 ALA CD#18.2)

ADOPTED, ALA CD#30.1, Resolution on Taxpayer Bill of Rights Laws (known as TABOR, TEL, SOS, etc.), which read:

“That the American Library Association opposes Taxpayer Bill of Rights Laws (TABOR), also known by other names such as Taxpayer Expenditure Limitations (TEL), Stop Over Spending Now (SOS) and other names, through the state legislatures or by state constitutional amendment; and that the American Library Association encourages state and regional library associations to oppose the passage of these laws, and take steps necessary to defeat such legislation or constitutional amendments.”

VOTED, That a task force of ALA Membership Committee and Budget Analysis and Review Committee members provide a plan for a graduated dues structure study for presentation to the ALA Council and the ALA Executive Board no later than the 2007 Midwinter Meeting. (2005-2006 ALA CD#33.2, Budget Analysis and Review Committee Report on 2006 Midwinter Council Resolution for a Graduated Dues Structure Study, ALA CD#38)

ADOPTED, ALA CD50, as amended to read:

“That the American Library Association Council urges all the relevant ALA units and the profession-at-large to highlight and explain the Darfur Genocide through collections, programs, displays, resource guides, and other suitable means; and that the ALA calls upon publishers to actively seek and publish materials at both lay and scholarly levels to add to public understanding of Darfur and other genocidal conflicts.”

APPROVED, The FY2007 Total ALA Budgetary Ceiling of $54,653,986 (ALA CD#13.4, ALA Treasurer’s Report)

ALA Council III
Tuesday, June 27, 2006
8:00am-12:30pm
Morial Convention Center, La Nouvelle Orleans Ballroom

ADOPTED, The following memorials: Henriette D. Avram; Ross Atkinson; Mary Jane Anderson; Lee Brawner; John Iliff; Daniel T. Lundy; Carole C. Callard; John McGowan; and Israel David Fishman.

ADOPTED, The following tribute: Resolution Dedicated to the City of New Orleans and Its Citizens.

ELECTED, To the 2006-2007 Council Committee on Committees: 86 Stephen L. Matthews; Barbara Genco; Bernadine Abbott-Hoduski; and Robert Randolph Newlen. (Council Tellers Report, ALA CD#12.3)

ELECTED, To the 2006-2007 Planning and Budget Assembly. Chapter Representatives: Sandra M. Barstow and Thomas Kevin Cherry. Councilor-at-Large Representatives: Bonnie L. Kunzel;
Katharine B. Lehman; and Theresa A. Tobin. (Council Tellers Report, ALA CD#12.3)

ADOPTED, The following two (2) ALA Bylaws amendments as identified in ALA CD#25.3, ALA Constitution and Bylaws Committee Report:

Item #1, Article III. Nominations & Elections: To amend the ALA Bylaw Article III, Nominations and Elections, Section 2(a) to read:

“The ALA Nominating Committee shall report its nominations at the Midwinter Meeting of the Council. The final list of the candidates’ names shall be reported in American Libraries.”

Item #2, Article III. Nominations & Elections: To amend theALA Bylaw Article III, Nominations and Elections, Section 4(b) as follows:

Insert a new Article III. Nominations & Elections, Section 4(b) to read:

“For every election of the Association, the Committee on Election shall establish a closing date for the membership list. Only members in good standing on that date shall receive a ballot and shall be entitled to vote.”

Renumber current Bylaw Article III, Section 4(b) to Section 4(c).

ADOPTED, The following nine (9) resolutions identified in ALA CD#20.7-ALA CD#20.16, ALA Committee on Legislation Report:

Item #1, Resolution on Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Libraries, ALA CD#20.8, which read:

“That the American Library Association urges Congress to direct the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to reprogram $2.5 Million of the EPA FY 2007 budget to fund EPA Libraries; and that ALA urges the EPA to restore funding to the EPA regional and laboratory libraries; and that ALA urges the EPA to develop a responsible information and collections management strategy, and make it available for public comment, to ensure continued access for the public and other stakeholders to the collections and services of the EPA Libraries.”

Item #2, Resolution on the Federal Research Public Access Act of 2006 (FRPAA), ALA CD#20.9, which read:

“That the American Library Association supports S. 2695, the Federal Research Public Access Act of 2006, as introduced, in that it reflects ALA policy regarding access to Federal government information by providing for the long-term preservation of, and no fee public access to, government-sponsored, published research findings.”

Item #3, Resolution on Saving Federal Libraries, ALA CD#20.10, which read:

“That the American Library Association urges Congress to affirm that the federal libraries are inherently governmental and the position of librarian is essential; and that ALA urges the United States Congress to hold oversight hearings investigating the ongoing destruction of federal libraries before they are lost beyond recovery; and that ALA urges Congress to adequately fund federal libraries so that they will be able to employ federal librarians with subject expertise to provide research services.”

Item #4, Resolution on Support of Online Social Networks, ALA CD#20.11, which read:

“That the American Library Association opposes the Deleting Online Predators Act as it is presently drafted; and that the American Library Association affirms the importance of online social networks to library users of all ages for developing and using essential information literacy skills; and that ALA asks library supporters to contact their representatives and senators to inform them about the important role `social networking sites’ serve in civic participation, collaboration, etc. and about problems caused by mandatory blocking as proposed in H.R. 5319; and
that the American Library Association communicates this resolution to the United States Congress and to others, as appropriate.”

Item #5, Resolution Affirming “Network Neutrality”, ALA CD#20.12, which read:

“That the American Library Association affirms the right of all library users to enjoy equal and equitable internet access free from commercial bias, whether provided in the library, or through remote access to library resources; that ALA reiterates its support for effective network neutrality legislation such as the Internet Freedom Preservation Act (S.2917) and the Network Neutrality Act of 2006 (H.R. 5273), and that the ALA supports the FCC’s codification of network neutrality principles, and that ALA calls upon library supporters to actively advocate for effective and enforceable network neutrality as telecommunications reform legislation proceeds in Congress.”

Item #6, Resolution Reaffirming the Need for Access to Advanced Communications Services and Support for Universal Service and the E-Rate Discounts for Libraries and Schools, ALA CD#20.13, which read:

“That ALA adopts the position that any proposed legislation and related regulations must assure universal service funding support for current and more advanced telecommunications services in libraries and schools; and that the American Library Association (ALA) supports proposals that exempt all universal service programs from Antideficiency Act accounting requirements; and that ALA calls upon all library supporters to advocate on behalf of the E-rate and universal service; and that ALA communicates this resolution to the United States Congress and to others as appropriate.”

Item #7, Resolution of Appreciation For Patrice McDermott, ALA CD#20.14, which read:

“That the American Library Association (ALA) congratulates Patrice in her new position as director of OpenTheGovernment.org; and that the ALA membership looks forward to collaborating with Patrice on issues of mutual interest; and that the ALA membership extends its sincere appreciation for Patrice’s tireless efforts on behalf of the Association and library users around the world and wish her continued success.”


Item #8, American Association of Law Libraries (AALL) Resolution on No-Fee FDLP Access to PACER, ALA CD#20.15, which read:

“That the U.S. Government Printing Office should negotiate with the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts to make the PACER system available at no cost to users of federal depository libraries; and that this resolution be forwarded to appropriate members of Congress, including the Joint Committee on Printing, the Administrative Office of the US Courts, and the Depository Library Council.”

Item #9, Resolution Endorsing HR 676 (For Single Payer Universal Heath Care and
S 2772, the Health Partnership Act.) ALA CD#20.16, which read:

“That the American Library Association endorses HR 676, “Expanded Medicare for All,” a single payer health care program; and that the American Library Association endorses S2772, “Health Partnership Act,” as a first step towards affordable quality health care for all; and that the American Library Association works with affiliated organizations and among our own membership to build popular support for these bills; and that the American Library Association sends a copy of this resolution to the President, to all Senators and Representatives.”

ADOPTED, The following three (3) resolutions identified in ALA CD#19.1-ALA CD#19.5, ALA Intellectual Freedom Committee Report:

Item#1, Resolution on the Retention of Library Usage Records, ALA CD#19.3, which read:

“That the American Library Association urges all libraries to:

• Limit the degree to which personally identifiable information is collected, monitored, disclosed, and distributed; and
• Avoid creating unnecessary records; and
• Limit access to personally identifiable information to staff performing authorized functions; and
• Dispose of library usage records containing personally identifiable information unless they are needed for the efficient and lawful operation of the library, including, but not limited to data-related logs, digital records, vendor-collected data, and system backups; and
• Ensure that the library work with its organization’s information technology unit to ensure that library usage records processed or held by the IT unit are treated in accordance with library records policies; and
• Ensure that those records that must be retained are secure; and
• Avoid library practices and procedures that place personally identifiable information on public view; and
• Assure that vendor agreements guarantee library control of all data and records; and
• Conduct an annual privacy audit to ensure that information processing procedures meet privacy requirements by examining how information about library users and employees is collected, stored, shared, used, and destroyed; and

That the American Library Association urges all libraries to adopt or update a privacy policy protecting users’ personally identifiable information, communicating to library users how their information is used, and explaining the limited circumstances under which personally identifiable information could be disclosed; and that the American Library Association urges members of the library community to advocate that records retention laws and regulations limit retention of library usage records containing personally identifiable information to the time needed for efficient operation of the library.”

Item#2, Resolution on National Discussion on Privacy, ALA CD#19.4, which read:

“That the Intellectual Freedom Committee, Intellectual Freedom Round Table, and Libraries Fostering Civic Engagement Membership Intitiative Group collaborate with other ALA units toward a national conversation about privacy as an American value.”

Item#3, Resolution to Commend the John Does of the Library Connection, ALA CD#19.5, which read:

“That the American Library Association strongly commends the stand of the Connecticut John Does—George Christian, Barbara Bailey, Peter Chase, and Janet Nocek—in their successful legal battle to defend the privacy of library user records; and that the American Library Association condemns the use of National Security Letters to demand any library records; and that the American Library Association reaffirms its opposition to sections of the USA PATRIOT Act that infringe on library patrons’ ability to access library services without privacy safeguards.”

VOTED, That ALA and Council committees are required to submit to Council an update of their activities within a month after each Midwinter Meeting or Annual Conference. (Committee on Organization Committee Report, ALA CD#27.1)

ADOPTED, Resolution on Lessons Learned from Meeting in New Orleans, ALA CD#53, as amended to read:

“That the American Library Association commends the members of the library community in the hurricane-affected areas for their tireless efforts to maintain a level of service that few thought would be possible after such a massive disaster and to restore valued library services for the people they serve; and that the American Library Association urges conference attendees to take full advantage of this ‘teachable moment’ to bear witness to the extent of the work that remains to be done here with their colleagues, employers, and communities at home; and that the American Library Association urges librarians to establish or strengthen their relationships with their state and local emergency planning agencies and offer their libraries' services in disaster preparation, response and recovery for the future; and that this document be distributed as the ALA Executive Director deems as appropriate; and that the American Library Association urges state chapters to contact and work with the ALA Chapter Relations Office staff to aid Gulf Coast libraries through means such as the Adopt-a-Library program.”

7.20.2006

American Dream Initiative

DEMOCRATS UNVEIL AFFORDABILITY PLAN
State block grants, restructured tax credit centerpieces of a
proposal aimed at increasing access to college--the American Dream Initiative.

7.18.2006

New Orleans Public Library Wish List at Alibris

Help to reestablish hurricane-devastated New Orleans Public Library
When New Orleans' levees broke under Hurricane Katrina's storm surge, a natural disaster became an urban catastrophe. Eighty percent of the city's area was inundated by water that remained in place for weeks. Total damage to the New Orleans Public Library System is estimated at over $18 million. As New Orleans has begun to recover, the New Orleans Public Library is renewing itself as well -- helping people get the information they need to rebuild their lives. With your support, the New Orleans Public Library is coming back better than ever. Please donate a book today!

NOPL Wish List.

7.17.2006

Walla Walla Newspaper Indexed by Inmates

Using inmates to index old newspapers is a winner
The public will benefit as more historic information will be easily available and inmates will have an opportunity to work and gain new skills.

It's been said that newspapers are the first draft of history.

That's certainly the case in Walla Walla where at least one newspaper has documented life in the Valley for nearly a century and a half. The Statesman dates back to 1861 while the Walla Walla Union began publishing in 1869.

There's a lot of Walla Walla's history to be found in those old newspapers, which are archived on microfilm at Whitman College's Penrose Library.

But few people have the time or the energy to comb through microfilm or old newspapers to find out about events of the past or their relatives. The newspapers aren't indexed.

That's changing.

Seventy-seven years of newspapers - from the start of the Civil War through the Great Depression - are now being indexed by 11 inmates at the Washington State Penitentiary.

For more on libraries and correctional institutions see : Interface.

7.12.2006

Spiral-Bound


Spiral-Bound is The Modern Word's electronic newsletter. Sent out every six weeks to subscribers as a link-embedded email, Spiral-Bound contains book reviews, literary news, features on literature-related art and music, information on important Libyrinth updates, and featured off-site articles, papers, or Web sites that we feel may inform or amuse enthusiasts of modern literature.
Spiral-Bound is a community effort, open to submissions and supported by an optional e-group devoted to the discussion of twentieth-century writing, criticism, and philosophy.

7.08.2006

Cambridge fair celebrates book arts

The 5th annual Book Arts and Printmaking Fair takes place July 15 at the Queen's Square branch of Cambridge Galleries and Design at Riverside Printmaking Studio.

Developed in response to Cambridge's manufacturing history in textiles, this specialized mandate makes the gallery unique among public galleries across southern Ontario.

Intended to "celebrate the beauty and craft of books" of all types, the fair includes displays, demonstrations and the sale of works spanning a wide range of the book arts and printmaking (private press printers, bookbinders, papermakers, handmade and limited-edition books and chapbooks, bookmaking and printmaking supplies).

7.05.2006

University of the Incarnate Word Dean [Mendell Morgan] and the NYTimes Cancellation

Incarnate Word cancels NY Times subscription over story


Comments from Inside Higher Education.

Incarnate Word and the 1st Amendment

Obviously, Incarnate Word does not believe in a free press. When information is suppressed, everyone—including governments—lose. Incarnate Word is preparing to return to the Dark Ages and the Days of Inquisition? SHAME

Arthur Ide, at 11:35 am EDT on June 30, 2006
Mendell Morgan, Grow Up!

When I first read that Mendell Morgan cancelled the Incarnate Word’s subscription to the New York Times because he disagreed with its latest scoop, I had reacted with dismay and amusement. If I had not known better I would have assumed that the person in questions was a spoiled teenager reacting impetuously to a decission that he/she did not agree with, such as not receiving enough money for allowance. That someone in that position can make such a petulant decision is very disturbing not only for the glaring lack of professionalism and maturity but for the blatant exposure of his own political bias. Had he also cancelled the subsciption to “The Weekly Standard” or “American Conservative” or “The Washington Times” then we would all know that his approach is balanced and in the spirit of respect for all viewpoints. What Mr. Morgan is trying to do is to control the dissemination of news, of knowledge. This is in direct contradiction of what his role is about. If he disagrees with the politices of a faculty member, would he deny him/her access to the library? He has opened himself to much criticism and deservedly so. If I were the president at the Incarnate Word, I would be extremely disconcerted by this irrational decision.

Tom, at 11:35 am EDT on June 30, 2006
NY Times

As an academic librarian, I seriously question the logic for any library dean to cancel a resource unilaterally. That said, this decision doesn’t strike me as anything but tilting at windmills. I suspect that the dean cancelled merely the print version of the NY Times; I quick look at their web site reveals that they still have a historic subscription (back to 1851) through Proquest, and a current electronic subscription through Gale and Lexis-Nexis.

In other words, for the university to “cancel” its subscription to the NYT, it will have to cancel its Lexis-Nexis subscription, too. If their dean is really looking to make a statement, I’d suggest he try to cancel Lexis-Nexis. Until then, his decision (with which I disagree, though that’s irrelevant to this point) doesn’t impress me a lick.

J Wiser, Librarian, at 1:05 pm EDT on June 30, 2006

University of the Incarnate Word...ever heard of them? No? Yeah, neither have I.

What is this guy thinking? I know it’s located in Texas, so I guess they’re backing their own. The funny thing is that 4 years ago the Bush Administration was touting this program publicy. Funny how in an election year when things look bleak they “create” controversy that will make them look strong on Ntional Sercurity.

What?!?!?, at 3:10 pm EDT on June 30, 2006

The First Amendment does not require any person or organization to fund activities or organizations with which they disagree. Incarnate Word is a private university and no more obligated to support the New York Times than they are to support Stormfront.

JD, at 3:30 pm EDT on June 30, 2006

Cancelling the Times, or any offering from a news venue is no worse than ending a comic book subscription. Faculty members need to stop crying about meaningless perks. Students have no respect for whiners.

Mike, at 4:55 pm EDT on June 30, 2006

Mr. Idle,While I disagree with IC’s decision to cancel the NYT, it is actually an exercise of first amendment rights, not a blow to it.

We have no national Pravda or Signel that all must subscribe to. Thankfully we have no requirement here to keep Mein Kampf or the Red Book on the coffee table. Boycotts are the private citizen’s right and while we may disagree with the specific cause, we should never belittle the right of the citizen to choose what to buy. So, yes there is a free press but I am also free to buy or not buy it.

That said, I don’t agree with their decision and also believe that this is a decision the administration should share in making. However, it is part having a free press, not an attack on it.

MTS, UConn, at 11:15 am EDT on July 1, 2006

First of all, I would have liked to have seen Morgan make a more specific judgment about how the NYT is of no use to scholars in the university. It’s “quality” has no bearing on that, as frequently people study blatant propaganda to understand propaganda. Indeed, some people even study the advertisements in magazines and newspapers. Because of this lack of specifics, I think Morgan is being a little silly. But it is cute.

Obviously Morgan isn’t the sharpest knife in the draw, but there is a heck of a lot of irony to most of his statements:

1) Mining SWIFT data (pursuant to an administrative subpoena) is probably the least legally questionable, and the most likely to be assumed to be taking place, anyway;2) Morgan doesn’t provide specifics about how such disclosure would actually imperil national security (since most people know that there is no 4th amendment interest in financial transactions);3) Morgan doesn’t provide specifics about how the New York Times’ coverage has declined apart from the most recent events;4) Morgan doesn’t provide specifics as to how such intelligence has resulted in anyone’s apprehension (so I think he made it up);5) Finally Morgan doesn’t explain how “National Security Policy” somehow encompasses an exception to the 1st amendment, requiring Americans to not care about things deemed to be “national security” and a potential source of something to vote upon.

His email was absolutely hilarious, and I hope he writes more of them, and they get passed around.

On a serious note academics should note that selectively canceling subscriptions or funding will jeopardize even a private university’s claim to academic freedom.

Larry, at 8:25 pm EDT on July 2, 2006

=
Checked out
By Char Miller
Morgan acted solely on the basis of a personal political agenda — “ ... the only action I know to register protest for their irresponsible action (treason?) is to withdraw support of their operations by canceling our subscription ... ” Yet it is precisely this reckless, first-person-singular approach to library management that the ALA prohibits in the code of ethics its members agree to uphold. To wit, sections VI and VII:

“We do not advance private interests at the expense of library users, colleagues, or our employing institutions.

We distinguish between our personal convictions and professional duties and do not allow our personal beliefs to interfere with fair representation of the aims of our institutions or the provision of access to their information resources.”

It is beyond me how Morgan can remain in his position as dean of this invaluable library, for even his partial — but-I-don’t-really-mean-it -recantation damages his and UIW’s reputations.

Editorial: Reinstating N.Y. Times corrects wrong message.
Web Posted: 07/05/2006 12:00 AM CDT.
San Antonio Express-News

7.04.2006

Master's Theses in Librarianship & the GLS

Has the dropping of the Master's Thesis contributed to a general decline in the ability of librarians to conduct, evaluate and assist with research?

My school, GLS at the University of Chicago, required the master's thesis. My advisor was Dr. Lester Asheim. The GLS has long since closed.
I'd never realized before reading Hérubel's essay the rate of decline.
In 1960 13.4% of all MLS graduates had written a thesis. By 1979 it was .04%.

Jean-Pierre V M. Hérubel
"Contextual Culture of the Master's Degree and the Decline of the M.L.S. Thesis: An Exploratory Review Essay" Libraries & Culture 40. pp. 63-84 Winter 2005.

See also:

Richardson, John, Jr. The Gospel of Scholarship: Pierce Butler and a Critique of American Librarianship. Metuchen, N.J.: Scarecrow Press, 1992.

________, The Spirit of Inquiry: The Graduate Library School at Chicago, 1921-1951. Chicago: American Library Association, 1982.

7.03.2006

Laura Bush at ALA in New Orleans

I left the American Library Association conference early because I did not want to be there when Mrs. Bush was there.
Here is more discussion of the matter.
--from the ALA Council Discussion list.

FYI: Response to Councilor Sue Kamm re: Laura Bush's appearance at ALA NOLA.
-----------------------------------------
I have it on the word of very good sources that Laura Bush inserted herself into the ALA programming by way of the Washington Office which, obligingly, at the behest of the President's Wife (AKA , "First Lady"), got her the podium at the New Orleans Conference for her cosmetic, PR appearance at the scene of one of her husband's administration's most egregious derelictions of domestic responsibility , the horrifying evidence of which was still there all around us, almost a year on, even as the vacuous smiley-face of the Administration cooed to the (smaller-than-expected?) audience at the AASL event at the newly-sanitized Convention Center from Hell, the epicenter of a vast human tragedy still being played out in New
Orleans.
In other words, if AASL wants to take the rap for it, fine. But Councilors and Members should know that it was-- at least according to my sources -- the collaboration of the Washington Office with the Administration which imposed this entirely unnecessary politicization on an ALA event and the conference as a whole.
I'm sure this is not what people want to hear, but the "hoo-hah" over the appearance of Laura Bush was the result of our Washington people doing her --and the Administration for which she stands-- an unearned favor in creating a perfect platform for political hypocrisy by a cheerful representative of those who have presided over the criminal neglect and abandonment of the people of New Orleans.
Mark Rosenzweig
ALA Councilor at large
(expressing my own bloody opinion!)

At 7:04 PM -0400 7/3/06, Sue Kamm wrote:
> >From assorted discussions on the Council floor and on this list, I wonder if we need to review the operating agreement ALA negotiated with its divisions. In the hoo-hah about Laura Bush's appearance at the Annual Conference, I don't recall anyone mentioning that a division sponsored her appearance, and - IMNSOHO - the program was
>the responsibility of AASL.
>As one might gather from my comments, I'm not sure what the agreement says, what kinds of constraints are placed on divisions (and other ALA units), and how the financial issues are addressed.
>
>Your friendly CyberGoddess and Councilor-at-large,
>Sue Kamm
>Inglewood/Los Angeles, CA
>Truest of the Blue, Los Angeles Dodgers Think Blue Week 2000

7.01.2006

When Do We Publish a Secret?

"When Do We Publish a Secret?" By DEAN BAQUET, editor, The Los Angeles Times, and BILL KELLER, executive editor, The New York Times
Published: July 1, 2006

....But the virulent hatred espoused by terrorists, judging by their literature, is directed not just against our people and our buildings. It is also aimed at our values, at our freedoms and at our faith in the self-government of an informed electorate. If the freedom of the press makes some Americans uneasy, it is anathema to the ideologists of terror.